What is the Difference Between Bulk and Break Bulk Cargo?

What is the Difference Between Bulk and Break Bulk Cargo?
Back to blog

What is the Difference Between Bulk and Break Bulk Cargo?

When dealing with international shipping, businesses often encounter terms that sound similar but represent very different concepts. Two such terms are “bulk cargo” and “break bulk cargo.” While they may seem interchangeable at first glance, these shipping methods have distinct characteristics and are suited for different types of goods. 

In this article, we will explore the differences between bulk and break bulk cargo, helping you gain a deeper understanding of these terms and their implications for your business’s shipping operations.

What is Bulk Cargo?

Bulk cargo refers to goods that are shipped in large, unpackaged quantities, typically in a ship’s hold or in specialized vehicles like rail cars or tanker trucks. These goods are homogeneous, meaning they are of the same type and not packaged or bundled together.

Definition of Bulk Cargo

Bulk cargo can be classified into two main categories: dry bulk and liquid bulk. 

Dry Bulk Cargo

This includes commodities such as grains (wheat, corn, soybeans), coal, iron ore, and fertilizers. These goods are often loaded directly into a ship’s hold using specialized equipment like conveyor systems or cranes with mechanical grabs. These systems are designed to handle large volumes of materials efficiently, with the capacity varying depending on the size of the equipment and the vessel being loaded. The loading process is designed to minimize the risk of contamination or damage to the cargo. Dry bulk cargo is typically transported in large volumes and often does not require individual packaging, making it economical for shippers. However, in some cases, smaller volumes of dry bulk cargo may be shipped in bags or containers.

Liquid Bulk Cargo 

This category encompasses materials like crude oil, petroleum products, chemicals (such as caustic soda and sulfuric acid), and even certain food products like vegetable oils and wine. These goods are transported using specialized tankers or pipelines, which are designed to maintain the integrity and quality of the liquid cargo during transit. Tankers are equipped with pumps and heating systems to facilitate the loading and unloading process, as well as to maintain the required temperature for certain products. Liquid bulk cargo relies on these pumps and pipelines to efficiently transfer the goods between storage facilities and ships or tankers. Careful handling and monitoring are essential to prevent leaks, spills, or contamination, which could lead to environmental and safety hazards.

What Ship Types Are Used for Bulk Cargo?

Bulk cargo is transported using specialized ships called bulk carriers, designed with large, open holds to accommodate unpackaged goods efficiently. 

The main types of bulk carriers include:

  • Gearless bulk carriers: These ships rely on shore-based equipment for loading and unloading cargo, making them suitable for ports with well-developed infrastructure.
  • Geared bulk carriers: Equipped with onboard cranes or conveyors, these ships offer flexibility in cargo handling and can operate in ports with limited infrastructure.
  • Combined carriers: Designed to carry both bulk and other cargo types, such as containers or break bulk, these ships provide versatility for shippers with diverse cargo requirements.
  • Self-unloading bulk carriers: Fitted with onboard conveyor systems, these ships can discharge cargo directly onto the shore or onto another vessel, making them ideal for quick unloading or ports with limited facilities.

The choice of bulk carrier depends on various factors, including the cargo type, port infrastructure, trading routes, and specific requirements. Additionally, advancements in ship design and technology have led to the development of specialized bulk carriers, such as ice-class vessels for trading in cold regions, and specialized eco-friendly designs that aim to reduce fuel consumption and emissions to meet the evolving needs of the global bulk commodity trade.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Bulk Cargo

Bulk cargo offers several advantages, including:

  • Lower shipping costs due to economies of scale.
  • Faster loading and unloading times.
  • Efficient use of ship space.
  • Suitable for commodities traded in large volumes.

However, bulk cargo also has some disadvantages:

  • Limited flexibility in terms of cargo types.
  • Requires specialized port infrastructure.
  • Higher risk of cargo contamination or damage.

What is Break Bulk Cargo? 

Break bulk cargo refers to goods that are transported in individually packaged units, such as boxes, crates, drums, or pallets. These goods are not containerized and are loaded and unloaded piece by piece.

Definition of Break Bulk Cargo

Break bulk cargo encompasses a wide range of goods that do not fit into the standard shipping containers or bulk cargo category. This type of cargo is typically heterogeneous, meaning it can include various items with different shapes, sizes, and packaging requirements.

What Types of Cargo Are Commonly Shipped as Break Bulk?

Break bulk cargo is suitable for a wide range of goods that cannot be easily containerized or shipped in bulk due to their size, shape, or special handling requirements. 

Some common examples of break bulk cargo include:

  • Machinery and equipment: Large, heavy, or irregularly shaped machinery and equipment, such as construction or agricultural machinery, that cannot fit into standard containers.
  • Steel products: Coils, plates, beams, and other steel products that are too large or heavy for containerization and require special handling and stowage.
  • Lumber and wood products: Lumber, plywood, and other wood products, that are typically shipped in bundles or on pallets, requiring careful handling to avoid damage.
  • Bagged cargo: Agricultural products, such as coffee beans, cocoa beans, or grains, that are shipped in large bags or sacks and require special handling to maintain quality.
  • Project cargo: Large, oversized, or unique items, such as wind turbine components, industrial equipment, or prefabricated structures, that require specialized handling and transportation.
  • Vehicles and rolling stock: Automobiles, trucks, buses, and other vehicles that are driven or towed onto and off the vessel, as well as railway rolling stock that is shipped on specialized roll-on/roll-off (RoRo) vessels.

Cargo Handling Equipment

Break bulk cargo requires specialized equipment for efficient handling and transportation. Unlike bulk cargo, which is moved in large quantities using conveyors or pipelines, break bulk cargo is handled as individual units. 

The most common equipment used for loading and unloading break bulk cargo includes cranes, derricks, and forklifts. These tools are designed to lift, move, and position the various types of break bulk cargo safely and efficiently. The handling process for break bulk cargo is generally more labor-intensive and time-consuming than that for bulk cargo or containers, as each unit must be handled separately. Additionally, roll-on/roll-off (RoRo) vessels are used for shipping vehicles and rolling stock, allowing them to be driven or towed directly onto and off the ship. 

What Types of Ships Are Used to Transport Break Bulk Cargo?

Break bulk cargo is transported using versatile multi-purpose vessels or general cargo ships. These ships are specifically designed with multiple decks and holds to accommodate a wide variety of cargo types, sizes, and shapes. This unique design allows for the efficient transportation of diverse break bulk goods. Similar to bulk carriers, break bulk ships can be classified as either geared or gearless. Geared break bulk ships are equipped with onboard cranes, allowing them to load and unload cargo independently. This feature is useful when docking at ports with limited shore-based cargo handling equipment. On the other hand, gearless break bulk ships rely on shore-based equipment, such as harbor cranes, for loading and unloading operations. The choice between geared and gearless break bulk ships depends on factors such as the intended trade routes, port infrastructure, and the specific requirements of the cargo being transported.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Break Bulk Cargo

Break bulk cargo offers the following advantages:

  • Greater flexibility in terms of cargo types and sizes.
  • Ability to ship smaller quantities.
  • Suitable for high-value or delicate goods.

The disadvantages of break bulk cargo include:

  • Higher shipping costs due to labor-intensive handling.
  • Longer loading and unloading times.
  • Increased risk of cargo damage during handling.

Break Bulk Cargo Vs. Bulk Cargo: What is the Difference?

While bulk cargo and break bulk cargo may sound similar, they are two distinct methods of shipping used for different types of goods. The main difference lies in the nature of the cargo itself and the way it is handled during transportation.

The key differences between bulk and break bulk cargo can be summarized as follows:

  • Cargo type: Bulk cargo is homogeneous and unpackaged, while break bulk cargo is heterogeneous and individually packaged.
  • Handling: Bulk cargo is loaded and unloaded using automated systems, while break bulk cargo requires manual handling and specialized equipment.
  • Flexibility: Bulk cargo is less flexible in terms of the types of goods it can accommodate, while break bulk cargo offers more flexibility for diverse and odd-shaped items.
  • Cost: Bulk cargo generally has lower shipping costs due to economies of scale and faster handling times, while break bulk cargo has higher costs due to labor-intensive handling and longer port stays.
  • Infrastructure: Bulk cargo requires specialized port infrastructure, such as storage facilities and handling equipment, while break bulk cargo can be handled at a wider range of ports.

The Bottom Line

As the global economy continues to grow, businesses that engage in international trade often find themselves navigating a complex landscape of logistics, regulations, and shipping options. Choosing the most effective shipping method, be it via containers, bulk, break bulk cargo, or even air freight, is just one of the many decisions that companies must make to ensure the smooth and efficient movement of their goods across borders.

Fortunately, businesses don’t have to tackle these challenges alone. 

By partnering with a reliable and experienced digital freight forwarder like Ship4wd, business owners can optimize their shipping operations and focus on what matters most: growing their business.

Ship4wd’s team of experts understands the intricacies of international shipping and can help businesses streamline their logistics processes, from planning and documentation to customs clearance and cargo tracking. With Ship4wd’s support, companies can rest assured that their shipments are in good hands and will be delivered from start to finish, whether they’re importing or exporting goods.

Don’t let the complexities of international shipping hold your business back. Sign up with Ship4wd today and start optimizing your shipping operations for success in the global marketplace.

Take control of your shipping

Sign up to create a new account
By signing up you are agreeing to terms & conditions